Not all Disasters are Created Equal (Part 1 of 2)
Aug 18, 2024
3 min read
0
22
0
When it comes to the Federal Casualty Loss Program, understanding the distinctions between "Federal Disasters" and "Qualified Federal Disasters" is crucial for taxpayers seeking to claim deductions for their losses. Both terms relate to events that cause significant damage or destruction, but they have different implications for tax relief.
Federal Disasters
A Federal Disaster is an event that has been declared a disaster by the President of the United States under the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act.
This declaration allows for federal assistance to be provided to affected areas and individuals. Examples include hurricanes, floods, earthquakes, and wildfires.
From a tax perspective, losses incurred due to a federally declared disaster can be deducted on your federal income tax return. However, these deductions are subject to certain limitations:
The loss must exceed $100 per casualty.
The total loss must exceed 10% of your adjusted gross income (AGI) for the year.
If you file Form 4684, you must itemize (i.e. you can't use the Standard Deduction)
Given the limitations of the 2017 tax code, that last bit can be a significant restriction. Most filers make out much better using the Standard Deduction. However, when you add on the 4684 deduction, you may be better off itemizing. Our Free Tax Recovery Estimator can tell you if this is the case.
Qualified Federal Disasters
A Qualified Federal Disaster is a subset of Federal Disasters that receive special designation by Congress. These disasters often result in more favorable tax treatment for affected individuals.
The key differences include:
No AGI Limitation: Unlike general federal disaster losses, qualified disaster losses are not subject to the 10% AGI reduction.
Increased Per-Casualty Deduction: The $100 per casualty reduction is increased to $500 for qualified disaster losses, but remember, you're not adjusting it by 10% of your income, so you're generally better off.
You don't need to itemize. You can file your taxes using the Standard Deduction, which is sometimes greater than your itemized deductions for a better treatment.
These distinctions mean that if your loss is due to a Qualified Federal Disaster, you can potentially claim a larger deduction with fewer limitations, providing more substantial financial relief.
Practical Implications
For taxpayers, understanding whether a disaster is classified as a general “Federal Disaster”, or a “Qualified Federal Disaster” can significantly impact the amount of deductible loss.
Here are some practical steps for an affected homeowner to take:
BEFORE YOU ARE A VICTIM OF A DISASTER: Take some pictures of your home and belongings. Create a “video inventory” – ie, just walk around your house with the camera running, describing all the possessions you feel are important. This will help establish a baseline and document your possessions for later. DO THIS TODAY! Then make sure the video gets uploaded to the cloud and does not get lost.
After a disaster, verify your Disaster Declaration at https://www.fema.gov/disaster/declarations
Every disaster has a code that you’ll need to file Form 4684.
Check the most recent instructions for Form 4684 which will list “Qualified” disasters. Currently (in 2024) you can refer to IRS Publication 547 and Form 4684 for detailed instructions on how to report your losses.
Keep detailed records of all losses. Take pictures of your property when you are hit, take pictures of the event if possible and the immediate aftermath, and when you rebuild, document this in photos as well showing the final result. Also keep all your receipts, and insurance claims paperwork.
Get a Professional Appraisal, like a Disaster Relief Loss Report. If you haven’t read our post about “Why can’t I use a Zillow estimate?” Please do so now. Having an appraisal will make it easy to file Form 4684 and protect you in case of audit.
By being informed about these distinctions, taxpayers can better navigate the complexities of the Federal Casualty Loss Program and maximize their potential deductions.
